DAILY MAVERICK SPECIAL EDITION
Wednesday, 17 January 2018
The saga explaining McKinsey's unethical behaviour is a long one. Starting as far back as June 2017, Daily Maverick has detailed each step of the consulting giant's pilfering of Eskom and subsequent self-explanation. Below is the complete A-Z of McKinsey's downfall that explains it all.
WHERE WE ARE TODAY
Scorpio: Gupta-linked McKinsey and Trillian ‘collusive and patently corrupt’ – Asset Forfeiture Unit
By JESSICA BEZUIDENHOUT for SCORPIO
“Without detracting from Trillian’s complicity in what is essentially theft of funds from Eskom, I submit that McKinsey played an instrumental role in syphoning the R1.6bn out of Eskom,” reads the statement in support of an application for a preservation order of the two companies assets.
FROM THE START
amaBhungane: McKinsey caught up in Trillian lies
Advocate Geoff Budlender’s report exposes how global consulting giant McKinsey got into bed with Trillian, in a “sham” contract that would milk Eskom of hundreds of millions of rands. By AMABHUNGANE
amaBhungane: Key findings from Budlender’s damning Trillian dossier
Geoff Budlender, the advocate appointed by former Trillian chair Tokyo Sexwale to probe “state capture” allegations against the company has delivered a damning report, despite what he characterises as Trillian's attempts to shut down his probe and starve it of information. Here are the highlights. By AMABHUNGANE.
It is now well-established that global consultants McKinsey and their local Gupta-linked counterpart Trillian extracted R1.6-billion in fees for “turnaround” advice given to Eskom. In this investigation, the first in a series, we delve into an explosive report that says Eskom ignored warnings that the proposed contract might be illegal, and reveal internal documents detailing how McKinsey and Trillian planned their multibillion-rand payday. The scandal has further dented Eskom’s image, already battered by a succession of “state capture” revelations. Now it is threatening the consulting companies too. Corruption Watch says it is alerting US authorities about McKinsey, while Trillian appears to be fighting to stay open. By Susan Comrie for AMABHUNGANE and Pauli van Wyk for SCORPIO.
In Part 1 of the #Guptaleaks: The McKinsey Dossier, we detailed how global consultancy McKinsey lined up a R9.4-billion bonanza from Eskom with the help of Gupta-linked Trillian Capital Partners. We also showed how Eskom executives ignored warnings from their own legal team that the contract favoured McKinsey and did not comply with the law. In Part 2, we show how the flawed contract – cancelled after queries from National Treasury – was nevertheless used to justify a massive settlement for McKinsey and its de facto empowerment partner, Trillian. By Susan Comrie for AMABHUNGANE and Pauli van Wyk for SCORPIO.
Eskom has moved to reclaim R1.6-billion paid to McKinsey and Trillian for a consulting project that left the power utility “open to excessive economic exposure”, according to a confidential report. By Susan Comrie for AMABHUNGANE and Pauli van Wyk for SCORPIO.
Scorpio & amaBhungane: The McKinsey Dossier, Part 4 – Bending over backwards for Trillian
Eskom paid Trillian R595-million without a valid contract while lying to the public about doing so. This is well established by now. But how the Gupta-linked company was sneaked onto Eskom’s payment system – a system designed to prevent fraud – has always been a mystery. A series of interviews and leaked documents show that suspended chief financial officer Anoj Singh and his management team stand accused of bending over backwards to get Trillian their payday, sometimes bullying mid-level officials into fabricating documents. By Pauli van Wyk for SCORPIO and Susan Comrie for AMABHUNGANE.
amaBhungane: The McKinsey Dossier, part 5 – How Transnet cash stuffed Gupta letterboxes
When global consulting firm McKinsey “came clean” last Tuesday about its work at Eskom, it admitted it was not careful enough about associating with Trillian, its de facto local partner. But it claimed not to have known that Gupta lieutenant Salim Essa owned most of Trillian. Now we show that at least R30-million flowed from Regiments, McKinsey’s longstanding local partner at Transnet, into companies associated with a notorious Gupta-Essa money laundering channel. McKinsey refuses to comment on the payments, styled as fees to “business development partners”. Once again, it was the major beneficiary of the resultant contracts. By Susan Comrie for AMABHUNGANE.
Scorpio: The McKinsey Dossier, Part 6 – Five strikes and you’re IN
Eskom ignored five legal opinions, some from within its own ranks, warning the power utility that its contentious “at risk” consulting contract with McKinsey was probably illegal. So nervous about the contract was McKinsey that its own in-house lawyer concluded Eskom would have to be “brave” in order to sign, newly leaked McKinsey documents show. Eskom should have been in no doubt that its proposed multi-billion rand contract was on shaky ground. They signed it anyway. By Pauli van Wyk for SCORPIO with AMABHUNGANE.
Curious and Curiouser: McKinsey’s astonishing attempt at self-exoneration
McKinsey’s “investigation” found nothing more to say about its dealings with Eskom and the Gupta-linked company Trillian than what the firm has already admitted to. Or what South Africans pieced together months ago thanks to whistle-blowers, civil society and journalists. In fact, neither the word “fees” nor the figure “R9.4-billion” in projected work for Eskom were mentioned in the global consulting giant’s lengthy statement on Tuesday. And yet, McKinsey said – they’ll pay back the money. By PAULI VAN WYK.
Scorpio: Gupta-linked Trillian and McKinsey’s assets to be frozen by order of High Court
By JESSICA BEZUIDENHOUT for SCORPIO
In one of the most significant moves in the anti-State Capture drive, South Africa’s Asset Forfeiture Unit obtained an urgent High Court order to seize and preserve assets belonging to the Gupta-linked Trillian and global consulting firm McKinsey just days before Christmas.
Newsflash: Asset Forfeiture Unit eyes R50-billion in state capture loot
The Asset Forfeiture Unit seems to be on a roll. The unit’s head of operations, Advocate Knorx Molelle, during a live television interview on Tuesday afternoon, confirmed that the preservation order obtained against global consulting firm McKinsey and Gupta-linked Trillian is but the first of several in the state capture investigation. By JESSICA BEZUIDENHOUT.